Area Coverage Studies with TAP4

Q: How do I use the Terrain Analysis Package (TAP)™ software for area coverage studies?

A: TAP includes a variety of functions that will help in the area coverage design process, as described below.

Since every situation is different, there is no "cookie cutter" approach. The following suggestions offer ideas of how the various TAP functions can be used in the process of designing your coverage system. Like any tool, the more you understand how the tool can be used, the better equipped you will be to adapt the tool to your particular circumstances.

(This article describes TAP functions for TAP5 and earlier.  For TAP6 and later versions, see the article for Area Coverage Studies with TAP.)

Site Selection

If the base station or repeater site location for the system is not already determined, several functions can help locate potential sites.

Point Elevation

Use the Point Elevation function (under the Topography menu in TAP) to determine the elevation of a site given the coordinates of the location. This enables you to compare the elevations of several sites in the area of interest. The Point Elevation form also includes an option to find the maximum elevation within a user-specified radius of a location. The topographic elevation data files provide the elevation of the potential sites. Naturally, final site selection should be based on elevations determined from a detailed USGS map or other source.

Area Grid

Use the Area Grid function (under the Topography menu in TAP) to extract the elevation values over a rectangular area. The data values can then be plotted in SoftWright's 3DDisplay program (or SURFER or other 2-D or 3-D plotting software) to give you a visual overview of the area, which may be useful in selecting potential sites. 

Sample Path Analysis

You can use the TAP point to point study features to evaluate the coverage to sample points in your target area.  The Path Profile program and the Single Point Field program can be use from a proposed or potential base station to selected points to look for line of sight and Fresnel zone clearance, and to compute the field strength at the locations.  For example, suppose you have three locations in the business district where a new repeater is intended to provide improved service.  You can quickly draw the path profiles from a potential site to each of those locations, and compute a field strength at each one.  If the results meet your requirements, then you can do more detailed coverage studies.  But if the sample calculations indicate that the site will not meet those requirements, you may be able to eliminate that site from consideration.

Path and Field Strength Preview

The TAP Path Preview and Field Strength Preview functions are similar to the sample path analysis described above.  The preview functions are more graphically oriented.  You can define a potential transmitter site and facility, then simply click at locations on a map to determine the intervening terrain and field strength value.  Once again, this gives you a tool for quickly determining the strengths and weaknesses of several potential base station or repeater sites.  The goal is to enable you to quickly eliminate sites which do not meet your needs so you can focus on the sites that will provide you the best coverage.

Comparative Studies

TAP offers the flexibility to use preliminary coverage studies in the site selection process.  For example, suppose you have five potential sites for a new repeater location.  You can use TAP to run studies from each of those sites, setting the study parameters for lower resolution studies that can be completed quickly.  The results of these preliminary studies may eliminate three of the five potential sites.  Then you can run additional and more detailed studies on the remaining candidate sites to determine which one provides the best solution to your coverage needs.  The details of setting the study parameters and the types of studies you can use are described below.

Coverage Calculations

Once base station or repeater site has been determined for your system, several features available in TAP for the design and evaluation of the area coverage system.

Shadow Study

Use the Shadow Study module (accessible in the Area Coverage function under the Coverage menu in TAP) to evaluate line of sight and Fresnel obstructions in the vicinity of a site. The shadow study can create a map showing areas that have line of sight from your base station (or from your remote station), as well as areas that have grazing or blocked paths.  You can add potential obstructions in the area (vegetation, ground clutter, buildings, etc.) using the Surface Feature editor.  These features will be included in determining the shadowing and line of sight locations in the shadow study, and can also be used in the path profiles and field strength studies described below.

Field Strength Study

Use the Area Coverage function to compute field strength values at numerous locations, based on the parameters of your base station.  Surface Feature files can be included in the coverage calculations using the advanced settings for a tile or radial coverage study. 

While the Shadow Study described above can give you general information on the line of sight and Fresnel zone clearance for a path to a target point, the actual value of the predicted field strength for different locations can be found from an area coverage study using one of the several propagation models available in TAP. This information will also be useful in selecting the best sites and the best paths for your point to point system.

You can also set up coverage studies from your remote locations to determine the field strength over the surrounding area. The areas of highest field strength would be a guide to the best base station to serve each of the remote locations.

Setting Up Area Coverage Studies

Fixed Facility Database

Enter (or import; see below) the facility information for your base and remote stations. The TAP Fixed Facility database (accessible from numerous forms in TAP, as well as the Editors menu) enables you to create and maintain an extensive database of facility information for base stations, remote stations, repeaters, etc. You can use the Fixed Facility editor in the design process by specifying the transmission lines, antennas, etc., and trying various configurations to meet the coverage requirements for your installation.

Once the parameters for a fixed facility have been entered into the database, that information can be used to define base stations or repeaters, shadow study or field study stations, and so forth. You can use the Fixed Facility database to enter existing facilities, proposed facilities, proposed modifications for existing facilities, etc.

Loss Values

In the Fixed Facility database enter various system loss values (connector loss, transmission line loss, etc.) to be used in computing the available power at a transmitter site or the needed input at a receiver site.

Transmission Line Library

In the Fixed Facility database, you can specify transmission line length and select a line type from a library and compute the line loss. (The Transmission Line Loss function is also available under the Utilities menu in TAP.)  By entering this information, as well as other loss values (connector loss, component insertion losses, etc.) the Fixed Facility database can be used as part of the design process for determining the best configuration for various facilities you want to use. In addition to the sample line specifications that come with TAP, you can enter additional values from line manufacturers for other lines you may want to use.

Antenna Library

In the Fixed Facility database, you can specify an antenna from a library and include the gain and directionality of that antenna in the field calculations for that facility. In addition to the sample libraries that come with TAP, you can enter antenna information with an editor, or you can use an import function to read antenna pattern information from a manufacturer into a TAP antenna library.

When you add an antenna to a Fixed Facility record, the antenna orientation information in the Fixed Facility record is used to compute the effect of the directionality of the antenna in different directions. You can set the orientation value and use the facility for a coverage study.  You can also create several records with different orientations to compare the coverage from those facilities to determine the best antenna orientation value.

Facility Import

You can enter Fixed Facility parameters into the database using the editor (in the Editors menu in TAP), or you can use an import function (in the File menu in TAP) to populate the database with information from an Excel spreadsheet, dBase file, ASCII files, etc. TAP 4.5 and later includes an update function used with the Fixed Facility import. Using that function you can import information (such as receiver sensitivity, transmitter power output, line type and length, etc.) and then the program will use that information to update other parts of the database, such as effective radiated power, required field strengths, etc.

Trial Configurations

You can enter various facility parameters (different power levels, antenna heights, etc.) as separate records in the Fixed Facility database. Then these facility records can be used in trial configurations to determine the best settings for your application.

Coverage Area

TAP provides three ways to define the coverage area to be computed.

Basic and Advanced Studies

Basic studies are the easiest to set up and are useful for most typical coverage applications.  Basic studies have the following characteristics:

Advanced Tile and Radial studies offer more flexibility in defining the coverage area to be computed.

Speed vs. Detail

Radial studies have the advantage for speed.  Since all the computed points are on the radials, the topographic elevation data for each radial is used for every target point on the radial.  Tile studies define the target points on a grid, so the topographic data along the path from the transmitter to each point is unique.  More time is required for Tile studies to obtain the needed topographic data.

Tile studies have the advantage of a more uniform presentation of the coverage area, since the target points are on a uniform grid.  Radial studies have the "spokes of a wheel" look, so that the distance between radials increases as you get farther from the transmitter.

TAP gives you the flexibility to use whichever type of study is best for your circumstances.  For example, if you are comparing coverage from ten potential repeater locations, you can quickly set up and run ten radial studies in batch mode.  Basic radial studies, especially if you specify every five or even every ten degrees (72 or 36 radials) will run quickly, giving you an immediate comparison of the merits of each of the ten sites.  When you narrow the options down to the best three sites you may want to run a more detailed radial study or tile study for each site.  For the final site  you select, you can use a tile study for the best presentation of the results.

Contour Interpolation

Contour studies using Broadcast and Carey propagation models compute the distance to the desired contour along each radial.  Other propagation models (Longley-Rice, Bullington, Okumura, etc.) are designed to compute field strength at discrete points.  Contours based on these models use the computed values along radials from the transmitter and interpolate the desired contour value from those points.

Topographic Data

The Topographic Data item under the Configuration menu enables you to define where TAP should look for topographic elevation data for coverage studies, path profiles, and any other function using elevation values.  Normally, you only need to make changes to the configuration when you first install TAP, or when you add or remove data files, or if you need to move data files.  The Config button on the Area Coverage Setup form enables you to view or change the configuration if necessary.  (Note that the configuration function will depend on the version of TAP you are using.  TAP 4.0 - 4.4 use an older configuration system, and TAP 4.5 and later use the TopoScript data retrieval engine.)

By default, TAP uses all of the available data files it finds based on the Topo Data Configuration settings.  If you want to select only certain data of a certain resolution for a particular study, you can select only the data you want.

The topographic elevation data available to TAP can be in a variety of file formats and resolutions.  You can set the topographic data increment for the path from the transmitter to each target point (tile or radial).

Propagation Model

For Area Coverage studies, you can select any of the propagation models which are licensed to your TAP system.  The available models for your TAP system are shown in the pulldown list on the Area Coverage Setup form.

Each propagation model has its own set of parameters that determine how the model will compute the field strength values.  You can enter or edit these values with the Edit button in the Propagation Model section of the form.

Mobile Facility Database

You can define the type of mobile unit to be used for the coverage calculation from the Mobile Facility Database.

An important parameter for evaluating the coverage area is the Required Field value for each type of mobile unit and each scenario.  The Area Coverage study in TAP computes and saves the field strength value at each location.  By applying the appropriate Required Field value(s) at each location, we can determine what mobile units will have enough signal to operate and under what circumstances.  The Required Field calculations, the Required Field settings, and the loss values to be considered are important parts of the area coverage study.

The coverage study is computed based on the one mobile facility you select, but the required field values for other scenarios can be included on the coverage plot as described below. 

Boundary Files

The Area Coverage Setup form enables you to include boundary files to be included on the coverage plot.  (If you enter coordinates for the transmitter site in the U.S., and the "Auto" box is checked, the default boundary file for the state where the coordinates are located is added.)  You can add or remove boundary files later on the coverage plot as described below.

 

Surface Features

For Advanced studies (Tile, Radial, or Contour) you can add obstacles in the area that may affect your coverage. You can import or create a database of buildings, vegetation or other "clutter" to be considered in addition to the topographic data (using the Surface Feature File function under the Editors menu in TAP). Path profiles, shadow studies, field strength studies, etc., can use this "Surface Feature" information to determine line of site, etc., considering buildings, vegetation, or other obstacles in the area.  You can also add surface features directly on the profile using the mouse.  You can also use USGS Land Use Land Cover information to determine the location of potential obstructions on a profile of the path or a map of the area.

Land Use Information

For Advanced studies (Tile, Radial, or Contour) USGS Land Use Land Cover information can be used in the study to adjust computed field strength values for the immediate environment of each computed location.  For example, the path from the base station to a particular area of the city may provide great line of sight and Fresnel zone clearance, resulting in a high predicted field strength value.  But if that location is in a heavily industrialized area, man-made noise could significantly affect the usability of the signal.  The Land Use information can be included in the study and the computed field strength can be reduced to model the effects of the rf noise in that area.  The amount of adjustment to the computed signal level is a function of frequency and the Land Use classification.  You can edit the existing values or create your own.

If Land Use information is not available for your area (such as outside of the U.S.) you can create your own Land Use data files for use in the coverage studies.

Coverage Maps

Once you have computed a coverage study (or several) you can draw a map of the coverage.  The coverage map can include a raster map background and boundary files showing county boundaries, roads, rivers, etc.  You can create your own customized boundaries as well as importing from ESRI ShapeFiles.

One or more coverage studies can be included on the map, and you can add any combination of tile, radial, and contour studies.

When you plot Tile or Radial studies, you can set the field strength level(s) and the associated color to represent each level.  The Field Levels typically are set to correspond to the Required Field values that are of interest to you.  The levels can be set directly from the information stored in the Mobile Facility Database.  For example, you can create a tile study coverage map where the green area represents the coverage area using a vehicle mounted mobile unit, the yellow area represents the coverage for a handheld under optimum conditions, and the red area shows coverage for handheld units with significant building or body losses.  This is how the different Required Field values are translated into useful information for showing the various levels of coverage in your system.

Note that the field strength calculations depend on the height of the mobile antenna, since that determines the geometry of the path, line of sight clearance, etc.  You should avoid using the same coverage calculation for mobile facilities with radically different antenna heights.  For example, if you compute a coverage area using a mobile antenna height of three feet above ground (for a belt-clip radio), the coverage would probably not be representative of the service for a vehicle with a ten-foot whip antenna.

You can include multiple coverage studies on the same map.  If you are showing Tile or Radial coverage calculations, normally the colors set for the field strength levels (as described above) are the same for each of the coverages.  In other words, the green area represents the same field strength level range regardless of what coverage study it is from.  The other option is to show a single field strength level, and use different colors to represent different studies.  With this setting you can distinguish between the field strength of the desired level from transmitter site A and that same value from site B.

There are a number of other options to enhance the presentation of the coverage map, such as adding a scale, a legend and notes, graphics, site information, etc. You can also export the coverage information for use in other mapping software that can import dBase files (.DBF) or read ShapeFiles (.SHP).

3DDisplay

With the 3DDisplay module you can draw the coverage study and topographic elevation data, boundary lines, and raster map in a 3D view to help you get a better idea of the coverage and the effects of the terrain.  The module gives you great flexibility in lighting, viewing angles, scaling, etc.

TalkBack Calculations

In addition to the calculations of the coverage area from the base station to the mobile units (the "talk-out" coverage), you can also compute the coverage area where mobile units can "talk-back" to the base station.  TAP uses the computed "talk-out" values for the area and considers the differences in gains and losses between the two systems (base to mobile, and mobile to base) to determine the "Talk-back System Margin."  When you plot a talk-back study, the colors represent not the actual field strength values, but rather the areas where talk-back is possible from the mobile units to the base station.

 

Aggregate Coverage

The TAP Aggregate Coverage module can be used to combine two or more studies computed with TAP.  This combination can be used to represent multiple transmitters from the same system, such as simulcast transmission, or for interference calculation from transmitter(s) from a different system.

The Aggregate Coverage program uses only tile studies, and all the studies included must cover exactly the same area and exactly the same target points.  (Defining the area and target points for use in multiple studies is facilitated by the Area Elevation Template described in the Advanced Tile study article.)  The Composite Study program gives more flexibility in combining tile (or even radial) studies that are not exactly coincident. 

While the Aggregate Coverage program provides more precision (since all the studies have computed the field strength at exactly the same points), the Composite Study program provides more flexibility, since it performs the calculations with points that are within a defined distance of each other.

 

Copyright 2004 by SoftWright LLC